The McKinsey Quarterly has come out with another interesting article, this time about stock buybacks.
In this article, the authors suggest that most company buyback programs don’t work the way they’re intended, to buy back stock when prices are low.
Most companies end up buying back stock at high prices, not at low prices.
It seems that companies, like many investors, are not good at market timing.
I suppose it’s human nature that companies initiate buyback programs when the company is doing well but the stock price seems to lags the fundamentals.
The irony is that companies typically don’t maintain buyback programs when a company’s situation is less favorable and its stock price has dropped.
The bias, therefore, is to buy back stock only at high prices.
The authors calculated that companies’ buyback programs would have been more successful if applied consistently over time, in good times or bad.
The SEC permits these programs, like 10(b)5 programs, to accomplish what the authors suggest.
I noticed in the article’s footnotes, however, that other academic studies have shown that smaller companies have used one-time purchases, like tender offers, to successfully buy back stock at low prices.
I can help you to evaluate which kind of stock buyback program best fits your company and on setting up the program.
Again, my name is Dennis McCarthy. Please contact me to discuss. Thank you.